Conversation
muhabalwan-aginx
requested a review
from helmut-hoffer-von-ankershoffen
as a code owner
|
muhabalwan-aginx
force-pushed
the
chore/pysdk-000-claude-doc-review
branch
from
ca5d2d9 to
c6c039d
Compare
|
Claude finished @muhabalwan-aginx's task —— View job Comprehensive PR Review - Complete ✅I have thoroughly reviewed PR #252 against the Aignostics Python SDK standards as outlined in CLAUDE.md. This PR adds a new 🚨 CRITICAL BLOCKING ISSUES1. ❌ Missing Abstract Method Implementation (BLOCKING - CI Failure)Location: Issue: The Impact:
Fix Required: Add these methods to from aignostics.utils import BaseService, Health, get_logger
class Service(BaseService):
"""Example service for demonstration purposes."""
def __init__(self) -> None:
"""Initialize the example service."""
super().__init__()
logger.info("Example service initialized")
def health(self) -> Health:
"""Check service health.
Returns:
Health: Service health status.
"""
return Health(status=Health.Code.UP, details={"module": "example"})
def info(self, mask_secrets: bool = True) -> dict[str, str]:
"""Get service information.
Args:
mask_secrets: Whether to mask sensitive information.
Returns:
dict[str, str]: Service information.
"""
return {
"module": "example",
"version": "1.0.0",
"purpose": "Learning template for SDK architecture",
"description": "Demonstrates modulith pattern with Service + CLI + GUI",
}
@staticmethod
def get_example_data() -> dict[str, str]:
# ... existing code ...Reference: See Verification: python -c "from aignostics.example import Service; s = Service(); print(s.health())"2. ❌ Missing Test Coverage (BLOCKING)Location: Issue: The new Current State: No test directory exists for this module. Fix Required: Create comprehensive test suite following repository patterns: File structure: Example test implementation ( """Tests for example module service."""
import pytest
from aignostics.example import Service
from aignostics.utils import Health
@pytest.mark.unit
def test_service_initialization(record_property) -> None:
"""Test example service can be initialized."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-SERVICE")
service = Service()
assert service is not None
assert service.key() == "example"
@pytest.mark.unit
def test_service_health(record_property) -> None:
"""Test service health check returns UP status."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-SERVICE")
service = Service()
health = service.health()
assert isinstance(health, Health)
assert health.status == Health.Code.UP
assert health.details["module"] == "example"
@pytest.mark.unit
def test_service_info(record_property) -> None:
"""Test service info returns expected structure."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-SERVICE")
service = Service()
info = service.info()
assert isinstance(info, dict)
assert "module" in info
assert "version" in info
assert "purpose" in info
assert info["module"] == "example"
@pytest.mark.unit
def test_get_example_data(record_property) -> None:
"""Test get_example_data returns expected structure."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-SERVICE")
data = Service.get_example_data()
assert isinstance(data, dict)
assert "message" in data
assert "status" in data
assert "module" in data
assert data["status"] == "active"
assert data["module"] == "example"
@pytest.mark.unit
def test_process_example(record_property) -> None:
"""Test process_example text transformation."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-SERVICE")
input_text = "test input"
result = Service.process_example(input_text)
assert result == f"Processed: {input_text}"
assert "test input" in resultCLI tests ( """Tests for example module CLI commands."""
import pytest
from typer.testing import CliRunner
from aignostics.example import cli
runner = CliRunner()
@pytest.mark.integration
def test_cli_hello_default(record_property) -> None:
"""Test hello command with default argument."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-CLI")
result = runner.invoke(cli, ["hello"])
assert result.exit_code == 0
assert "World" in result.stdout
@pytest.mark.integration
def test_cli_hello_custom_name(record_property) -> None:
"""Test hello command with custom name."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-CLI")
result = runner.invoke(cli, ["hello", "Alice"])
assert result.exit_code == 0
assert "Alice" in result.stdout
@pytest.mark.integration
def test_cli_data(record_property) -> None:
"""Test data command."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-CLI")
result = runner.invoke(cli, ["data"])
assert result.exit_code == 0
assert "Example Data" in result.stdout
@pytest.mark.integration
def test_cli_process(record_property) -> None:
"""Test process command."""
record_property("tested-item-id", "SPEC-EXAMPLE-CLI")
result = runner.invoke(cli, ["process", "test text"])
assert result.exit_code == 0
assert "Processed: test text" in result.stdoutIMPORTANT: All tests MUST have markers ( Verification: uv run pytest tests/aignostics/example/ -v
uv run coverage report --fail-under=853. ❌ Missing Module Documentation (BLOCKING)Location: Issue: Root CLAUDE.md line 38 states: "Every module has detailed CLAUDE.md documentation." The example module violates this requirement. Fix Required: Create Required structure: # CLAUDE.md - Example Module
## Module Overview
The example module is a learning template that demonstrates the Aignostics SDK's modulith architecture pattern.
**Purpose**: Educational template showing best practices for:
- Service layer implementation with BaseService
- CLI command registration with Typer
- GUI page integration with NiceGUI
- Module auto-discovery via dependency injection
**User Interfaces**:
- **Service**: Core business logic (get_example_data, process_example)
- **CLI**: Three commands (hello, data, process)
- **GUI**: Interactive page at /example route
## Architecture & Design Patterns
### Service Layer
- Inherits from `BaseService`
- Implements required `health()` and `info()` methods
- Provides static utility methods for example operations
- No external dependencies beyond utils
### CLI Layer
- Uses Typer for command registration
- Three demonstration commands showing different patterns:
- `hello`: Positional argument with default
- `data`: No arguments, calls service layer
- `process`: Required argument, processes input
### GUI Layer
- PageBuilder pattern for auto-discovery
- Interactive UI demonstrating service integration
- Accessible at `/example` route
- Shows cards with example data and text processing
## Development Guidelines
### Adding Features
1. Add business logic to `_service.py`
2. Add CLI commands to `_cli.py`
3. Update GUI in `_gui/_page_example.py` if needed
4. Write tests in `tests/aignostics/example/`
### Testing Strategy
- Unit tests for service methods
- Integration tests for CLI commands
- GUI tests if nicegui available (optional)
- Maintain 85%+ coverage
## Usage Examples
### Programmatic Usage
```python
from aignostics.example import Service
service = Service()
data = service.get_example_data()
processed = service.process_example("hello world")CLI Usage# Say hello
uv run aignostics example hello
uv run aignostics example hello "Alice"
# Get example data
uv run aignostics example data
# Process text
uv run aignostics example process "sample text"GUI Access# Launch GUI and navigate to /example
uv run aignostics guiDependencies
Key Files
### 📚 example
**Learning template demonstrating SDK modulith architecture**
- **Core Features**: Service layer pattern, CLI/GUI integration, dependency injection demo
- **CLI**: Three demonstration commands (`hello`, `data`, `process`)
- **GUI**: Interactive example page with service integration
- **Dependencies**: `utils` only
- **Purpose**: Educational reference for creating new modules
* [src/aignostics/example/CLAUDE.md](src/aignostics/example/CLAUDE.md) - Example learning module5. ❌ Commit Message Convention Violations (BLOCKING)Location: All 5 commits in this PR Current commits: Issue: None follow conventional commit format required by CLAUDE.md line 1123: Valid types: Fix Required: On merge, squash all commits with a proper conventional commit message: 6.
|
|
Claude finished @muhabalwan-aginx's task —— View job PR Review - Complete ✅I've thoroughly reviewed PR #252 against the Aignostics Python SDK standards. This PR adds a new Review SummaryBlocking Issues Found: 3 critical issues preventing CI from passing 🚨 CRITICAL BLOCKING ISSUES1. ❌ Import Error:
|
|
Claude finished @muhabalwan-aginx's task —— View job Comprehensive PR Review - PR #252I've conducted a thorough review of this PR against the Aignostics Python SDK standards as documented in CLAUDE.md. This PR adds a new 🚨 CRITICAL BLOCKING ISSUESThese issues MUST be resolved before merge. They are causing CI failures and violating core architecture requirements. 1. ❌ Import Error:
|
helmut-hoffer-von-ankershoffen
force-pushed
the
main
branch
4 times, most recently
from
172df4a to
b8afdff
Compare
|
2 participants
No description provided.