Skip to content

Wrong IMAS DD version in STEP_SPP_001_EBCC_freeboundary.nc #3

@timothy-nunn

Description

@timothy-nunn

When running ncdump STEP_SPP_001_EBCC_freeboundary.nc | grep .data_dictionary I get the following output, implying that the data uses version 4.0.0 of the IMAS data dictionary:

:data_dictionary_version = "4.0.0" ;
        string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary ;
                string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:_FillValue = "" ;
                ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:documentation = "Version of Data Dictionary used to PUT this IDS" ;
     ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary = "4.0.0" ;
        string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary ;
                string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:_FillValue = "" ;
                ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:documentation = "Version of Data Dictionary used to PUT this IDS" ;
     ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary = "4.0.0" ;
        string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary ;
                string ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:_FillValue = "" ;
                ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary:documentation = "Version of Data Dictionary used to PUT this IDS" ;
     ids_properties.version_put.data_dictionary = "4.0.0" ;

I believe this is wrong for two reasons:

  1. @fcasson states in Update README.md #2 that the data dictionary version is 3.x
  2. The equilibrium data is not consistent with COCOS 17 (which would be required for it to be IMAS DD version 4 https://imas-data-dictionary.readthedocs.io/en/latest/cocos.html#cocos)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions